Question:
With Friends Like These...
Update: An Afghan who risked all to rescue a wounded Navy SEAL finds trouble with the Taliban—and the U.S. military
Newsweek Web Exclusive
By Sami Yousafzai
Death threats from the Taliban aren't Mohammad Gulab's only worry. As reported in NEWSWEEK's April 17 issue, the Afghan villager has been pursued by Al Qaeda's local partners ever since June 2005, when he rescued a wounded U.S. Navy SEAL in the mountains of Kunar province, east of Kabul. Vengeful jihadists burned down his village lumber business and forced him and his family to flee for their lives, abandoning their home and possessions. The Americans never delivered on promises Gulab says they made to relocate the family to a safe place, so they moved in with Gulab's brother-in-law near the U.S. base at the provincial capital, Asadabad. But Gulab never expected that the American military would target him next.
Late on Friday, April 14—the week NEWSWEEK's story appeared—Gulab's phone rang. The caller told him to come to the U.S. base at 11 the next morning, and Gulab barely slept that night, thinking the Americans were going to relocate him and his family out of danger. When he reported to the main gate on Saturday, he found a pair of U.S. soldiers waiting for him. They checked his name—and then handcuffed and blindfolded him, hauling him off to an unlit room in a remote corner of the base. There, he says, he was placed in a cage so cramped that he could neither stand up nor lie down.
Hours later, two Americans and an interpreter entered the room and began interrogating him. Most of the questions were about his life and his family, although Gulab couldn't imagine why. He was sure his captors knew exactly who he was, he says. They inquired about ties to al Qaeda, a question he considered insulting. Hadn't he saved an American commando's life? And the interrogators kept returning to the subject of his contacts with NEWSWEEK. They had searched him and found a NEWSWEEK reporter's business card with an Islamabad address. The interrogators kept asking when he had been to Pakistan and where had gone, although he told them he had not traveled to the Pakistani capital.
Gulab says the session lasted more than an hour. It was only the first in a series that continued until the afternoon of the fourth day. Then the Americans told him he was free to go home. He had trouble walking after spending so much time locked up in a cramped cage. His captors never told him why he had been detained, he says, but before his release, one of the interrogators offered some advice: Stay away from reporters. It will be in your best interest.
NEWSWEEK has repeatedly asked the U.S. military to clarify the incident. Lt. Col. Paul Fitzpatrick, a public-affairs officer at U.S. headquarters in Bagram, sent this reply via email: Mr. Gulab was detained and questioned by coalition forces and released. I can't discuss any details of why he was questioned but it was not related to his interview with Newsweek. The Pentagon has not responded to several requests for comment. The Taliban and its friends are not so reticent. After word got out that the Americans had locked up Gulab, someone left a message affixed to the wall of his brother-in-law's house. This is your punishment from God in this world, the note said, and a taste of what you will get on the day of judgment. Gulab continues to believe he did the right thing by saving the SEAL.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/12773520/site/newsweek/
Answer:
Oh this makes Americans look sooooo bad.
Answer:
^They are bad. We should of treated that man like a hero for risking his life and his family to save one of our guys. Many people wouldn't of bothered.
Answer:
omg, he's SUCH a good person and shouldn't be treated this way!!!! *(&)(*&(!!!
Answer:
WTH? Why was he treated like that? (IMG:style_emoticons/default/mad.gif) He deserves better.
Answer:
They probably wanted to question:
1. why and how al-qaeda contacted him.
2. last known communication and location of al-qaeda members who contacted him.
3. why and how he knew the whereabouts of a navy seal
4. If he had leaked any confidential information about the mission the navy seal was on, as well as his name and his location of rescue to the media.
5. They ask about pakistan, because it is believed Osama Bin Laden is in the mountains of Pakistan.
This is really such a limited view of what happened. It's completely one-sided and doesn't represent the whole picture. It's like taking bits and pieces of information and drawing a conclusion off of it.
Answer:
roar.. that's really horrible.
and if they were so worried that he work with al Qaeda--shouldnt they realize that if he helped them, they wouldn't be hunting him down with death threats? He helped save someone's life, and they can't even help him when he and his family are in danger..
Answer:
And of course the story blows things completely out of proportion, while dummying down other things.
Answer:
They probably wanted to question:
1. why and how al-qaeda contacted him.
2. last known communication and location of al-qaeda members who contacted him.
3. why and how he knew the whereabouts of a navy seal
4. If he had leaked any confidential information about the mission the navy seal was on, as well as his name and his location of rescue to the media.
5. They ask about pakistan, because it is believed Osama Bin Laden is in the mountains of Pakistan.
This is really such a limited view of what happened. It's completely one-sided and doesn't represent the whole picture. It's like taking bits and pieces of information and drawing a conclusion off of it.
i'm sure they had good reasons to detain him and ask him questions. But I think it's pretty cold of them to just let this man go and leave him and his family in danger of retaliation, even after the Newsweek's story.
Answer:
that's horrible! that kind of shows other people that it's best not to help the u.s. soldiers? what the... to go through all that trouble... he should be hailed as a hero!
Answer:
that poor guy... i can't believe the americans did that
Answer:
Okay, what the crap?
Yeah, I'm sure they probably had a good reason to ask him questions.
But to just leave him and his family in danger,
After he helped save an American sodier's life?
I say that's pretty cold.
They should've at least relocated him and thanked him. -_____-
Answer:
This is Newsweek with the story. The same magazine who claimed the Koran was flushed down toilets by military personell at Gitmo. Turned out the story was false and many muslims were killed while rioting over the story.
Stop believing everything you read. There is definately more to this than what Newsweek is telling you.
Answer:
Nevermind the humanitarian missions our military performs in over a 100 countries all over the world. The public really wants to read about the bad stuff the military does... fabricated or not.
Answer:
This makes us look terrible. First a man saves one of our dudes, then we lock him up?!
Answer:
this is a really nice story for a movie scenario
Answer:
I had a really long comment ready BUT I thought it was too much so I didnt post it up.
I just hope that they had GOOD reasons for doing such, cause that is definitely NOT how you repay a man who has just saved your friend's life.
